I do as requested and add, "Oh look, there's a teaspoon as well."
I don't recognize it.
"That's mine!" exclaims Surfer Dude, "Chuck it over here."
"You need it right now?" I say incredulously.
After a short pause to think, he adds, "Yes."
"So I'm guessing, for weeks now, you've been emptying your washing up bowl and not found a teaspoon at the bottom, and you desperately miss it."